Pumpkin Treat (Any pumpkin + sugar): Cows produce pumpkin spice milk, hens lay orange eggs, llamas produce orange wool.Midnight Treat (Cowberry jam + obsidian egg): Cows produce obsidian milk, chickens become evil, hens lay obsidian eggs, llamas produce black wool.Healthy Treat (Any fruit/any vegetable + any lettuce): Increases the lifespan of an animal.Golden Treat (Cowberry jam/honey + golden egg): Cows produce golden honey milk, chicken will become a golden chicken, hens will lay golden eggs, llamas produce golden wool.
Here are all the animal treats, their ingredients, and the animal treats' effects in one easy spot for you. If your Sim has purchased animal treats from the shops in Henford-on-Bagley or won them in some manner, they'll have the recipe for those treats and can make them in the kitchen.
